Jay W. McWatters CPA

Jay W. McWatters



Assurance Services Group

At a glance

Jay joined Dopkins in 2003 and serves as a leader in the Firm’s Assurance Services Department.   His primary areas of practice include manufacturing and distribution, and he also has experience serving defense and construction contracting, retail and charitable/tax exempt organizations.  Jay entered the public accounting profession immediately upon graduating from St. Bonaventure University in 1980. Prior to joining Dopkins, Jay spent 23 years with a Big Four accounting firm where he served as lead partner for their Upstate New York (Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse) audit practice and was Buffalo office Managing Partner.

Jay has a particular specialization in the field of agricultural cooperatives, especially dairy and fruit product producers. In addition to serving as lead engagement partner on a number of large and mid-sized audit engagements, Jay is also active in the delivery of a variety of consulting services including risk assessments, internal audit assistance, internal controls, governance, mergers and acquisitions and, financing transactions, among others.

Principal areas of expertise

  • Cooperatives
  • Cooperative governance
  • Financing
  • Mergers & acquisitions
  • Internal audit / internal controls
  • Manufacturing
  • Risk assessment / management
  • Sarbanes-Oxley
  • Transaction Advisory Services
  • Revenue Recognition Standard Implementation Services


  • Certified Public Accountant, Licensed in New York State, Massachusetts and Vermont

Professional Affiliations

  • National Council of Farmer Cooperatives, Member Legal, Tax and Accounting Committee; Chair, Financial Reporting and Audit Subcommittee; Chair, Revenue Recognition Working Group
  • KeyBank Western New York Advisory Board
  • Canisius College Council on Accountancy
  • National Society of Accountants for Cooperatives
  • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
  • New York Society of Certified Public Accountants


  • M.B.A., University of Scranton
  • B.S. in Accounting from St. Bonaventure University

Community Service

  • Member, Catholic Health System Board of Directors; Chair, Compliance Committee; Vice-Chair, Audit Committee
  • Member, Bishop’s Finance Council, Catholic Diocese of Buffalo
  • Former Treasurer; United Way of Buffalo and Erie County Board of Directors
  • Co-Chair, United Way of Buffalo and Erie County Annual Campaign (2014-2015)
  • Past Chair, Shea’s Performing Arts Center, Board of Directors

Awards & Achievements

  • Listed, Who’s Who in Banking and Finance, published by Business First of Buffalo

Speaking Engagements & Industry Experience

  • Instructor, State University of New York at Buffalo M.B.A. LeaderCore program (2017)
  • Speaker, Building a Process for Risk Assessment and Control, Northeast Cooperative Council Annual Meeting & Leaders Forum in Syracuse, NY (March 2017)
  • Adjunct Professor of Accounting, St. Bonaventure University

Blog Posts

Join Our Team

Whether you are evaluating career opportunities as an accountant, business consultant or IT professional, you'll want to know what differentiates Dopkins & Company from all the competition. Learn more today.